Catastrophe Bonds: A New Approach to Disaster Risk Management in India

Reference

Given the increasing impact of climate change and natural disasters, it has become necessary for the Indian financial system to adopt the concept of Disaster Risk Insurance. Most of the population of India is facing unexpected damage and loss. Catastrophe Bonds or Cat Bonds can be an effective solution to deal with this situation.

About Cat Bonds

• Origin: Globally, after the storms in America in the 1990s, when re-insurance companies also went into losses, catastrophe bonds started.
• Definition: This bond is a special type of financial product, which is a mixture of insurance and debt. These are also called 'Cat Bonds'.
  • It transfers disaster risk from insurance companies to global financial markets.
  • It is designed as a tradable security, which transfers the risk of natural disasters to investors.
• Purpose: To provide quick funds for relief and reconstruction after a disaster.
• Features: This bond covers the risk of specific disasters, such as earthquake, cyclone or flood.
• Benefits: Faster payout and lower risk than general insurance.

Disaster Bond Operation Process

• Process:
  • A country or organization (sponsor) issues a bond and pays a premium.
  • The principal of the bond serves as the insurance amount.
  • If no disaster occurs, the investor gets back the principal and interest of the bond.
  • If a specified disaster (e.g. a 6.6 magnitude earthquake) occurs, part or all of the principal is used for relief work and the investor suffers a loss.
• Risk and interest: The interest on a disaster bond is higher than a normal bond (1-2% for an earthquake, more for a cyclone) because investors take on more risk.
• Example: If India issues a CAT bond of $100 million and there is no earthquake, the investor gets the amount along with interest. But if there is an earthquake, the amount goes into reconstruction.

Disaster bond issuer stakeholders

• Sponsor:
  • Sovereign nations: Such as India, Mexico or the Philippines, which sponsor bonds to reduce disaster risk.
  • State governments: For disaster risk in specific areas.
• Intermediary:
  • World Bank: Helps in issuing bonds and managing risk.
  • Asian Development Bank (ADB): For regional catastrophe bonds.
  • Reinsurance companies: Such as Swiss Re, which assess and manage risk.
• Investors:
  • Pension funds: Largest investors, who want risk diversification.
  • Hedge funds and family offices: With a risk appetite.

Benefits of catastrophe bonds for investors

Catastrophe bonds are attractive to investors because they provide risk diversification.

• Risk freedom
  • Disaster risks (such as earthquakes, cyclones) are not related to financial markets (such as the stock market).
  • According to Nobel laureate Harry Markowitz, this risk diversification is like a 'free profit' for investors.
• Higher interest rate: CAT bonds have a higher coupon rate than normal bonds, which is an incentive in exchange for risk. • Portfolio stability: Disaster risk is not affected by market fluctuations, keeping the investor's portfolio stable.
• Global demand: Since the 1990s, $180 billion of CAT bonds have been issued, of which $50 billion are currently active.

Financial relief in extreme weather events

Disaster bonds can provide financial relief in extreme weather events, such as cyclones, floods and forest fires.

• Quick payment: When a disaster strikes, the principal of the bond is immediately available for relief and reconstruction.
• Risk transfer: It helps governments reduce dependence on insurance companies and raise funds from global financial markets.
• Example: Mexico issued CAT bonds with the World Bank in 2017, which provided quick relief after the earthquake.
• Potential in India: Given the increasing incidence of cyclones (such as Amphan) and floods in India, CAT bonds can protect public finances.

India as a Lead Sponsor for South Asia

India’s economic stability and regional leadership make it a leading sponsor of CAT bonds for South Asia.

India’s Strengths

• Economic Credibility: India’s strong credit rating makes the bonds cost-effective.
• Risk Profile: South Asia faces diverse risks such as earthquakes (Nepal, Bhutan), cyclones (India, Bangladesh) and tsunamis (Sri Lanka, Maldives).
• Experience in Natural Disasters: India has allocated $1.8 billion per annum (from 2021-22) in disaster management, which shows its commitment to risk mitigation.
• Regional Leadership: India can sponsor a regional CAT bond for South Asian countries, which will reduce premium costs by sharing the risk.

Potential for Regional CAT Bonds

• Risk Diversification: The variety of disasters (earthquakes, cyclones, floods) in South Asia creates a balanced risk profile.
• Benefits: Will reduce regional bond premiums and make funds available for disaster relief to all countries.
• Intermediary: Organisations like World Bank or ADB will not be able to provide funds for disaster relief to India
• Example: A regional bond for earthquake (Nepal, India), cyclone (Bangladesh, India) or tsunami (Sri Lanka).

Challenges in implementing catastrophe bonds

• Design errors: If the bond is not designed perfectly (example: a 6.6 magnitude earthquake is determined but a 6.5 magnitude causes heavy damage), then the payout may not happen. Mistakes in risk assessment can increase premium costs.
• High cost: The premium paid may seem futile if the disaster does not occur. High risk bonds like cyclones have higher premiums.
• Lack of awareness: The concept of catastrophe insurance and CAT bonds is new in India, which requires awareness building among investors and policy makers.
• Regulatory complexities: Regional bonds require coordination and policy coherence among South Asian countries.
• Investor interest: The investor base (pension funds, hedge funds) for CAT bonds in India is still limited.

Way Forward: Key Steps

• Risk Assessment and Design
  • Accurate bond design based on scientific data (e.g. earthquake intensity, cyclone frequency).
  • Collaboration with intermediaries like World Bank.
• Awareness campaigns
  • Awareness among investors and public regarding utility of CAT bonds
  • Integrating disaster insurance in financial literacy programmes
• Regional Cooperation
  • Agreement for regional CAT bonds with South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) countries
  • Develop policy framework for risk sharing
• Disaster Mitigation
  • Increase investment in disaster management and infrastructure to reduce premium costs.
  • Improve early warning systems and infrastructure
• Investor incentives
  • Encourage pension funds and hedge funds to invest in CAT bonds
  • Offer tax benefits or other incentives
• Pilot projects
  • Introduce small-scale CAT bonds (e.g. for cyclones) in India
  • Move to regional bonds based on success

Conclusion

Catastrophe bonds can be an innovative and effective way for India and South Asia to deal with natural disasters. It not only provides quick financial relief but also secures public finances by sharing risk with global financial markets.